How Region Scoopers Grew Past 700 Recurring Pet Waste Clients in Northwest Indiana
John Noonan, Owner ·Region Scoopers · Northwest Indiana
Built Local Podcast with Clay Lawrence · · 48 min episode

The short version
John Noonan started Region Scoopers in Northwest Indiana as a side job while he was laid off from union construction, then went full time after he was robbed at gunpoint on a job site. Answering every call, testing Facebook ads around a first-scoop-free offer, billing every four weeks and tracking his numbers took the pet waste removal company to a little over 700 recurring clients and nearly 800 Google reviews.
What other owners can take from Region Scoopers
- 1
Answer the phone. If you cannot, pay a per-minute answering service to do it, because the caller's next move is to call your competitor.
- 2
Launch 10 to 20 Facebook ads at once, let them run, and turn off any ad whose cost per lead climbs to around $50.
- 3
Test your offer. For Region Scoopers, first scoop free beat both 50% off the first month and one month free.
- 4
Tie the free scoop to prepayment: clients pay for four visits up front and get five.
- 5
Bill every four weeks instead of on the first of the month. The price is easier to explain and it does not land on the same day as the mortgage.
- 6
Use raw phone photos and selfie videos in ads. They outperformed professionally shot content.
- 7
Keep marketing to old leads and cancelled clients every season. You already paid for them.
How did Region Scoopers start in Northwest Indiana?
Region Scoopers started as a winter side job. John Noonan was in the laborers union, digging holes and installing gas lines about an hour from Chicago, when he was laid off for the winter. He had just bought a house, and unemployment would not cover the mortgage and bills.
He had been watching Erica Krupin’s YouTube videos about poop scooping, so he posted in Facebook buy and sell groups that he was doing it. He was embarrassed at first. “It was the best decision I’ve ever made,” he said. Within about two months he had around 20 clients, and he had 20 to 30 recurring clients when his boss called him back to work.
His dad took over the route. John left the house at 3 a.m. for construction, got home around 7 p.m., and showed up at the job site an hour early on purpose to schedule emails and answer leads. He ran the business that way for about two years.
What pushed John Noonan to go full time?
A robbery did. Around noon one day, in what he called a very nice neighborhood, three men with guns got out of a car and took everything from John, a co-worker and an inspector. He stayed away from work for about a month. His mom told him not to go back at all, because he had built the business for a reason.
“I think that was the push I needed to go full time,” he said. He had enough recurring clients for two technicians by then. Revenue almost doubled the next year: “We did like 125 for that year. The next year we did 245.”
Region Scoopers now has a little over 700 recurring clients and a team of nine. John hoped to reach about 850 by the end of the year.
Why does Region Scoopers make sure every call gets answered?
Because a caller who gets no answer calls the next company. “If no one answers the phone, I’m calling the next person,” John said.
When demand first took off after the snow melted, he had a waiting list of about 50 people, and his very first review was a one-star from someone he got back to two days later. He could not pick up with a dump truck backing up behind him, so he hired a virtual assistant company in Washington state that charges only for the minutes it spends on the phone. The team sent quotes in Jobber and scheduled jobs. He still uses them after hours.
Which Facebook ads and offers work for pet waste removal?
Simple ones, tested in volume. Early on John ran one picture with one caption at $20 a day and hoped it worked. Now the company launches 10 to 20 different ads on day one and kills the ones that do badly. When he ran the ads himself, he turned an ad off once its cost per lead reached about $50. Someone else runs them for him now.
What the testing showed:
- First scoop free beat every other offer. He also tried one month free and 50% off the first month.
- The free scoop comes with prepayment. New clients pay for four visits on the phone and get five.
- Raw beats polished. His best ad was a photo of him with his arms crossed, leaning on the wrapped truck beside a bucket and rake. Second best was a selfie video shot on his phone in front of the truck.
Why does Region Scoopers bill every four weeks?
Because the price is easier to explain and fewer cards decline. For its first few years the company charged on completion, which meant more fees and no revenue for a week that was skipped. Then it tested first-of-the-month billing.
John listens to his office’s sales calls and tracks where people drop off. In his example, a caller hears a $20 weekly rate, expects about $80 a month, and then hears a higher number, because the weekly rate is multiplied by 52 and divided by 12. To the caller it feels like being ripped off. The first of the month is also when the mortgage is due, so cards declined. Prepaid billing every four weeks eased both problems.
What numbers does John track to stay profitable?
Yards per hour, complaint rate, churn and take-home profit. His technicians average 2.5 to 3 yards an hour because yards in his area are bigger. The minimum price is $22 for a weekly visit, which includes hauling the waste away and a free return visit if anything is missed. The company also holds private events for clients only.
In his first two years payroll ran about 45% and he did not pay himself, because construction paid him over $100,000. Now a bookkeeper meets with him monthly on goals and budget. Take-home profit was 25% this year, down from 30% last year as he paid the team more and spent more on marketing. He called 20% a healthy target.
What would he tell another pet waste business owner?
Follow up, and do not stop. The first automation he would set up is quote follow-up by text and email, then seasonal offers to old leads and cancelled clients. Region Scoopers still markets to leads from 2021, the year it started. He uses ResponsiBid with Jobber for instant quotes and follow-up, and pointed owners without a system toward a CRM such as GoHighLevel.
He also credited Review Harvest for taking the company from around 120 to 130 Google reviews to nearly 800.
The rest is persistence. “Entrepreneurship is one of the most hardest things you can do, and it’s lonely,” he said. His advice to anyone in the middle of it was to keep pushing and to reach out to other scoopers, him included, when they get stuck.
In John's words
“There's really no secret golden nugget thing that's going to change your business. It's just do a good job, provide a great experience, and just keep doing it.”
“If you're giving your average, mediocre effort, you're going to get mediocre results.”
“You have your nine-to-five, but your business needs to be your five to nine.”
“You already paid for that lead. So squeeze the heck out of them until they opt out or tell you to buzz off.”
Review Harvest Client
What Region Scoopers says about Review Harvest
John says Region Scoopers has used Review Harvest for years. The company had around 120 to 130 Google reviews when it started and was nine short of 800 at the time of the episode, and he says about 30% of clients who get a request leave a review. He calls it the most hands-off system he has and the one that converts best, and says a client who signed up that week chose Region Scoopers only because of the review count.
“It's the most hands-off thing that I have that converts the best. It takes the least amount of effort from me, but it converts the highest.”

John Noonan on working with Review Harvest: “Why Review Harvest Is This Business Owner's Best-Converting System”
Questions this episode answers
How did Region Scoopers get to 700 recurring clients?
Region Scoopers in Northwest Indiana started with posts in Facebook buy and sell groups, which brought owner John Noonan about 20 clients in two months. After he went full time he learned Facebook ads, put a per-minute answering service on the phones so every call was answered, and built follow-up systems in Jobber and ResponsiBid. The company now has a little over 700 recurring clients.
What Facebook ad offer works best for a pet waste removal business?
For Region Scoopers, first scoop free outperformed one month free and 50% off the first month. The free visit is tied to recurring service: a new client pays for four visits up front and gets five. John Noonan says his best ads were a simple photo of him leaning on the wrapped truck with a bucket and rake, and a selfie video shot on his phone.
Why does Region Scoopers bill every four weeks instead of monthly?
John Noonan says first-of-the-month billing was hard to explain on the phone, because a monthly price is the weekly rate times 52 divided by 12 and comes out higher than callers expect. It also hit cards on the same day as the mortgage, which caused declines. Region Scoopers switched to prepaid billing every four weeks and saw fewer declined cards.
What is a healthy profit margin for a pet waste removal business?
John Noonan of Region Scoopers says his take-home profit is 25% this year and was 30% last year, and that 20% is a healthy number to aim for. He adds that margins are usually thinner early on, when an owner is spending heavily on ads and still learning. In his own first two years payroll ran about 45% and he did not pay himself.
How did Region Scoopers get nearly 800 Google reviews?
Region Scoopers had around 120 to 130 Google reviews when it started using Review Harvest and was nine reviews short of 800 when the episode was recorded. John Noonan says about 30% of the clients who receive a request leave a review. He says a recent client signed up only because the company had almost 800 reviews and the next competitor had about 70.
What software does Region Scoopers use?
Region Scoopers runs on Jobber, with ResponsiBid connected to it for instant quotes and automated follow-up at each stage of the customer journey. It uses a per-minute virtual assistant company for after-hours calls, Facebook ads for new leads, and Review Harvest for Google reviews.
Need pet waste removal in Northwest Indiana? Visit Region Scoopers at regionscoopers.com.


